The reason they are different is that the validate button assumes your import file contains the entire company user data. If therefore your import file is not a complete file, but rather is an incremental import, some managers are not in the import file.
As the complete company hierarchy is not in the file, it is impossible for our system to do a complete and accurate validation. Therefore you are likely to receive different error messages on-screen than you receive in your email notification.
If the on-screen validation errors are of concern to you, please contact SuccessFactors Customer Success for an explanation of the errors received before completing your import.
KBA , sf bizx system/platform , LOD-SF-PLT , Foundational Capabilities & Tools , Problem
SAP SuccessFactors HCM Core all versions